When the Light Went Red: The Climb to 895

@twigsplit May 15, 2025 Post #5

There’s no clean answer to who the greatest goal scorer in NHL history is, and that’s part of what makes the debate so rich. It’s not a stat you can sum up with one number. Raw totals, goals per game, playoff dominance, longevity, efficiency, era context, each tells a different story. Depending on how you weigh those variables, the crown could belong to four very different players: Mike Bossy, Mario Lemieux, Wayne Gretzky, or Alex Ovechkin.

Measuring Greatness

On April 6, 2025, Alex Ovechkin scored his 895th career goal, passing Wayne Gretzky for the most in NHL history. The goal came in the second period on the power play, a familiar wrist shot from the left circle. He did it in his twentieth season, matching Gretzky in games played, but with a different kind of flair: fewer assists and more muscle. When you zoom in on goal-scoring titles, Ovechkin’s dominance over his peers and place among the greats becomes apparent.

Ovechkin’s run since 2007–08 is the modern standout, hitting 50+ goals consistently while the rest of the league struggles to crack 40 most years. The game is tighter, and goalies are athletic freaks, yet he’s still outpacing everyone.

He’s won the Rocket Richard Trophy a record nine times (2007–08, 2008–09, 2012–13, 2013–14, 2014–15, 2015–16, 2018–19, 2019–20, 2021–22). Before 1998–99, there wasn’t an official “goal-scoring title” trophy, but we can count the times a player led the league in goals.

Player	Year	Team	Games	Goals	Points	Runner-Up	Goals
Leon Draisaitl	2024–25	Edmonton	71	52	106	William Nylander	45
Auston Matthews	2023–24	Toronto	81	69	107	Sam Reinhart	57
Connor McDavid	2022–23	Edmonton	82	64	153	David Pastrňák	61
Auston Matthews	2021–22	Toronto	73	60	106	Leon Draisaitl	55
Auston Matthews	2020–21	Toronto	52	41	66	Connor McDavid	33
David Pastrňák (Tie)	2019–20	Boston	70	48	95	Alex Ovechkin (Tie)	48
Alex Ovechkin	2018–19	Washington	81	51	89	Leon Draisaitl	50
Alex Ovechkin	2017–18	Washington	82	49	87	Patrik Laine	44
Sidney Crosby	2016–17	Pittsburgh	75	44	89	Nikita Kucherov/Auston Matthews	40
Alex Ovechkin	2015–16	Washington	79	50	71	Patrick Kane	46
Alex Ovechkin	2014–15	Washington	81	53	81	Steven Stamkos	43
Alex Ovechkin	2013–14	Washington	78	51	79	Corey Perry	43
Alex Ovechkin	2012–13	Washington	48	32	56	Steven Stamkos	29
Steven Stamkos	2011–12	Tampa Bay	82	60	97	Evgeni Malkin	50
Corey Perry	2010–11	Anaheim	82	50	98	Steven Stamkos	45
Sidney Crosby (Tie)	2009–10	Pittsburgh	81	51	109	Steven Stamkos (Tie)	51
Alex Ovechkin	2008–09	Washingtons	79	56	110	Jeff Carter	46
Alex Ovechkin	2007–08	Washington	82	65	112	Ilya Kovalchuk	52
Vincent Lecavalier	2006–07	Tampa Bay	82	52	108	Dany Heatley	50
Jonathan Cheechoo	2005–06	San Jose	82	56	93	Jaromír Jágr	54
Ilya Kovalchuk	2003–04	Atlanta	81	41	87	Rick Nash/Jarome Iginla	41
Milan Hejduk	2002–03	Colorado	82	50	98	Markus Näslund	48
Jarome Iginla	2001–02	Calgary	82	52	96	Mats Sundin/Bill Guerin/Glen Murray	41
Pavel Bure	2000–01	Florida	82	59	92	Joe Sakic	54
Pavel Bure	1999–2000	Florida	74	58	94	Owen Nolan	44
Teemu Selänne	1998–99	Anaheim	75	47	107	Jaromír Jágr/Tony Amonte/Alexei Yashin	44
Teemu Selänne	1997–98	Washington	73	52	86	Peter Bondra	52
Keith Tkachuk	1996–97	Phoenix	81	52	86	Teemu Selänne	51
Mario Lemieux	1995–96	Pittsburgh	70	69	161	Jaromír Jágr	62
Peter Bondra	1994–95	Washington	47	34	43	Jaromír Jágr	32
Pavel Bure	1993–94	Vancouver	76	60	107	Brett Hull	57
Teemu Selänne (Tie)	1992–93	Winnipeg	84	76	132	Alexander Mogilny (Tie)	76
Brett Hull	1991–92	St. Louis	73	70	109	Kevin Stevens	54
Brett Hull	1990–91	St. Louis	78	86	131	Theo Fleury/Cam Neely/Steve Yzerman	45
Brett Hull	1989–90	St. Louis	80	72	113	Steve Yzerman	62
Mario Lemieux	1988–89	Pittsburgh	76	85	199	Bernie Nichols	70
Mario Lemieux	1987–88	Pittsburgh	77	70	168	Craig Simpson	56
Wayne Gretzky	1986–87	Edmonton	79	62	183	Tim Kerr	58
Jari Kurri	1985–86	Edmonton	78	68	131	Mike Bossy	61
Wayne Gretzky	1984–85	Edmonton	80	73	208	Jari Kurri	71
Wayne Gretzky	1983–84	Edmonton	74	87	205	Michel Goulet	56
Wayne Gretzky	1982–83	Edmonton	80	71	196	Lanny McDonald	66
Wayne Gretzky	1981–82	Edmonton	80	92	212	Mike Bossy	64
Mike Bossy	1980–81	New York	79	68	119	Marcel Dionne	58
Charlie Simmer (Tie)	1979–80	Buffalo	76	56	89	Danny Gare/Blaine Stoughton (Tie)	56
Charlie Simmer	1979–80	Los Angeles	64	56	101	Danny Gare	56
Blaine Stoughton	1979–80	Hartford	80	56	100	Charlie Simmer	56
Mike Bossy	1978–79	New York	80	69	126	Marcel Dionne	59
Guy Lafleur	1977–78	Montreal	78	60	132	Mike Bossy	53
Steve Shutt	1976–77	Montreal	80	60	105	Guy Lafleur	56
Reggie Leach	1975–76	Montreal	80	61	91	Guy Lafleur	56
Phil Esposito	1974–75	Boston	78	61	127	Guy Lafleur	53
Phil Esposito	1973–74	Boston	78	68	145	Rick Martin	52
Phil Esposito	1972–73	Boston	78	55	130	Mickey Redmond	52
Phil Esposito	1971–72	Boston	76	66	133	Vic Hadfield/Bobby Hull	50
Phil Esposito	1970–71	Boston	78	76	152	Johnny Bucyk	51
Phil Esposito	1969–70	Boston	76	43	99	Gary Unger	42
Bobby Hull	1968–69	Chicago	74	58	107	Phil Esposito	49
Bobby Hull	1967–68	Chicago	71	44	75	Stan Mikita	40
Bobby Hull	1966–67	Chicago	66	52	80	Stan Mikita	35
Bobby Hull	1965–66	Chicago	65	54	97	Frank Mahovlich	32
Norm Ullman	1964–65	Detroit	70	42	83	Bobby Hull	39
Bobby Hull	1963–64	Chicago	70	43	87	Kenny Wharram/Stan Mikita	39
Gordie Howe	1962–63	Detroit	70	38	86	Camille Henry	37
Bobby Hull	1961–62	Chicago	70	50	84	Gordie Howe/Claude Provost/Frank Mahovlich	33
Bernie Geoffrion	1960–61	Montreal	64	50	95	Frank Mahovlich	48
Bronco Horvath (Tie)	1959–60	Boston	68	39	69	Bobby Hull (Tie)	39
Jean Béliveau	1958–59	Montreal	64	45	91	Dickie Moore	41
Dickie Moore	1957–58	Montreal	70	36	84	Gordie Howe	33
Gordie Howe	1956–57	Detroit	70	44	89	Jean Béliveau/Maurice Richard	33
Jean Béliveau	1955–56	Montreal	70	47	88	Gordie Howe/Maurice Richard	38
Maurice Richard (Tie)	1954–55	Montreal	67	38	59	Bernie Geoffrion (Tie)	38
Maurice Richard	1953–54	Montreal	70	37	67	Gordie Howe	33
Gordie Howe	1952–53	Detroit	70	49	95	Ted Lindsay	32
Gordie Howe	1951–52	Detroit	70	47	86	Bill Mosienko	31
Gordie Howe	1950–51	Detroit	70	43	86	Maurice Richard	42
Maurice Richard	1949–50	Montreal	70	43	65	Gordie Howe	35
Sid Abel	1948–49	Detroit	60	28	54	Jim Conacher/Roy Conacher/Ted Lindsay/Harry Watson	26
Ted Lindsay	1947–48	Detroit	60	33	52	Elmer Lach	30
Maurice Richard	1946–47	Montreal	60	45	71	Bobby Bauer	30
Gaye Stewart	1945–46	Toronto	50	37	52	Max Bentley	31
Maurice Richard	1944–45	Montreal	50	50	73	Herb Cain	32
Doug Bentley	1943–44	Chicago	50	38	77	Herb Cain/Lorne Carr/Carl Liscombe	36
Doug Bentley	1942–43	Chicago	50	33	73	Joe Benoit	30
Lynn Patrick	1941–42	New York	47	32	55	Roy Conacher/Red Hamill/Bryan Hextall Sr	24
Bryan Hextall	1940–41	New York	48	26	47	Roy Conacher/Sweeney Schriner	24
Bryan Hextall	1939–40	New York	48	24	40	Woody Dumart/Milt Schmidt	22
Roy Conacher	1938–39	Boston	47	26	37	Toe Blake/Alex Shibicky	24
Gordie Drillon	1937–38	Toronto	48	26	52	Georges Mantha	23
Larry Aurie (Tie)	1936–37	Detroit	45	23	42	Nels Stewart (Tie)	23
Charlie Conacher (Tie)	1935–36	Toronto	44	23	38	Bill Thoms (Tie)	23
Charlie Conacher	1934–35	Toronto	48	36	57	Cecil Dillon	25
Charlie Conacher	1933–34	Toronto	48	32	52	Marty Barry	27
Bill Cook	1932–33	New York	48	28	50	Busher Jackson	27
Charlie Conacher	1931–32	Toronto	44	34	48	Bill Cook	33
Charlie Conacher	1930–31	Toronto	38	31	43	Bill Cook	30
Cooney Weiland	1929–30	Boston	44	43	73	Dit Clapper	41
Ace Bailey	1928–29	Toronto	44	22	32	Nels Stewart	21
Howie Morenz	1927–28	Montreal	43	33	51	Aurel Joliat	28
Bill Cook	1926–27	New York	44	33	37	Babe Dye/Howie Morenz	25
Nels Stewart	1925–26	Montreal	36	34	42	Carson Cooper	28
Babe Dye	1924–25	Toronto	29	38	46	Aurel Joliat	30
Cy Denneny	1923–24	Ottawa	22	22	24	Babe Dye	17
Babe Dye	1922–23	Toronto	22	27	39	Billy Boucher	23
Punch Broadbent (Tie)	1921–22	Ottawa	24	31	45	Babe Dye (Tie)	31
Babe Dye	1920–21	Toronto	24	35	40	Cy Denneny	34
Joe Malone	1919–20	Quebec	24	39	49	Newsy Lalonde	37
Newsy Lalonde	1918–19	Montreal	17	23	32	Odie Cleghorn	21
Joe Malone	1917–18	Montreal	20	44	48	Cy Denneny	36

Bobby Hull tops everyone else with seven (1959–60, 1961–62, 1963–64, 1965–66, 1966–67, 1967–68, 1968–69), and Phil Esposito won six titles in a row (1970–71 to 1975–76).

Wayne Gretzky led the league in goals five times (1981–82, 1983–84, 1984–85, 1986–87, 1990–91). Before the modern era, Maurice 'Rocket' Richard, Gordie 'Mr. Hockey' Howe, and Charlie Conacher each matched that total. Mario Lemieux led the league four times.

Ovechkin’s nine clearly stands alone. No one in NHL history has led the league in goals more often. He won his first title in 2007–08 and his last in 2019–20, meaning those nine wins came over 13 seasons, an even more absurd stat.

Among his peers, the gap is glaring. Over those 13 seasons, only Sidney Crosby and Steven Stamkos won more than once, and both trail Ovechkin’s career total by over 250 goals. Historically, his 65 goals in 2007–08 was the most in a season since Lemieux’s 69 in 1995–96 and wasn’t broken again until Auston Matthews scored 69 in 2023–24.

Chasing the Crown

When looking at the full scope of separation from their peers, it’s Gretzky’s statistical dominance that is unparalleled, with his assist total alone outpacing everyone else’s total points. He finished his career with 894 goals and 1,963 assists for a total of 2,857 points in 1,487 games. It’s worth repeating: if you strip away all his goals, every single one, he’d still have the most points ever, from assists alone.

Even against today’s stars, it holds up. Crosby has 1,687 points (625 goals, 1,062 assists) in 1,352 games as of now, and Gretzky’s assists alone still top that total by nearly 300 points. Connor McDavid, the current pace-setter, has 1,082 points (361 goals, 721 assists) in 712 games, insane production, but Gretzky’s assist total is almost double that, achieved over a longer career but still in fewer games than most legends played.

The “no goals, still the best” stat is a testament to Gretzky’s playmaking genius. He didn’t just score; he elevated everyone around him. His single-season record of 163 assists in 1985–86 is more than every other player’s career high in points, except for Lemieux, who topped it twice.

For perspective, McDavid’s career high is 153 points (2022–23), and Crosby’s is 120 (2006–07), with a career-high 138-point pace in an injury-shortened 2011–12. Gretzky’s assist peak dwarfs those. There is no argument as to who the greatest player is, and Gretzky being at the top of the record books for goals was more a byproduct of his overall greatness than of his pure goal-scoring ability.

Ovechkin passing him in goals is a monumental achievement and a tribute to his durability and shot, but Gretzky’s overall point record is a different beast. The game has evolved, with better goaltending and tighter defenses, and even in his era, Gretzky lapped the field. He was four points away from having five straight 200-point seasons. Enough said.

These records are unlikely to be broken. The modern NHL doesn’t produce 200-point seasons anymore. McDavid’s 153 was a throwback, yet still 59 shy of Gretzky’s 212. A player would need Gretzky’s vision, longevity, and an era shift back to wide-open hockey. For now, Ovechkin may take the goal crown, but Gretzky’s point totals and throne remain untouchable.

Numbers Without Limits

Looking at the full history of goal-scoring titles, a few things really jump out. First, the early days of the NHL, back in the late 1910s and 1920s, were obviously a different time. Joe Malone put up 44 goals in just 20 games in 1917–18, which is insane efficiency. Assists weren’t even tracked properly back then, so the point totals look modest, but those goal numbers were huge for the time.

Then fast-forward to what could be called the peak scoring era, the 1980s and early ‘90s. That’s when the floodgates opened. Gretzky’s 92 goals in 1981–82 is still the gold standard, and Brett Hull’s 86 in 1990–91 wasn’t far off. The game was wide open, less defensive structure, goalies with smaller pads, and the top guys feasted. It’s a stark contrast to today.

Malone is a hidden gem when you put his numbers in context and might deserve a spot among the greatest. He led the NHL in goals twice in its first three seasons, 44 goals in 1917–18 and 39 in 1919–20. That 44-goal season with the Montreal Canadiens is wild when you realize it came in just 20 games.

That’s 2.2 goals per game, a pace that dwarfs anything we’ve seen since. For comparison, Gretzky’s 92 goals in 1981–82 came over 80 games, a rate of 1.15 goals per game. Ovechkin’s best, 65 in 2007–08, was 0.79 per game over 82. Malone was more than doubling their output per night.

The era helps explain it. The NHL was brand new, and the game was raw. No forward passing in the offensive zone meant individual skill ruled, and “Phantom Joe” was a cut above. Teams played 20–24 games back then, so totals look smaller, but his dominance was clear. Nobody else in 1917–18 even hit 30 goals.

In context, Malone’s case is wild. He’s not just a relic, he might be the purest goal-scoring machine ever. His marks held up like a fortress for decades, which really hammers home how ahead of his time he was.

His 44 goals in 1917–18 stood as the single-season record until Maurice Richard finally topped it with 50 in 1944–45, a gap of 27 years. And that 39-goal season from 1919–20? It was only eclipsed once in that same stretch, by Cooney Weiland’s 43 in 1929–30. For nearly three decades, nobody could touch Malone’s peaks, even as the league grew and seasons got longer.

The NHL went from 20-game schedules to 50 by the 1940s, giving players double or triple the chances to score, yet Malone’s 44 and 39 were untouchable. Weiland’s 43 in 44 games was a monster year, but it still took 12 years after Malone’s 39, and another decade until Richard cracked 40.

If you prorate 44 in 20 over 50 games, he’s at 110 goals, a number that makes Gretzky’s 92 look tame. Even adjusting for era, it’s unreal. And his 39 in 24 prorates to 81 over 50, still elite.

It took the game evolving, more games, better sticks, a shift to team play, for those records to fall. The longevity of Malone’s records, holding firm from 1917 to 1944, might just seal his case as one of the greatest pure scorers ever.

Origins of Dominance

Moving on, Mike Bossy wasn’t just a great goal scorer, he was the most efficient, lethal, and consistent one the league has probably ever seen. He hit 50 goals in nine straight seasons to start his career, something no one else has done. His career goals-per-game rate is still the highest in NHL history at 0.762, even above legends like Gretzky, Lemieux, and Ovechkin.

What sets Bossy apart is that he wasn’t padding stats late in his career or hanging on to reach milestones. Every season he played, he was elite, and then he retired in his prime.

If the metric is pure goal scoring, accuracy, release, consistency, production relative to games played, it’s hard to put anyone definitively above him. Longevity knocks him off a lot of all-time lists, but if the conversation is how good were they at scoring goals, period, his numbers make a terrifyingly strong argument.

Bossy wasn’t piling up goals on a weak team with nothing to show for it. He was doing it as the centerpiece of a dynasty. The Islanders won four straight Stanley Cups from 1980 to 1983, and Bossy was a driving force the entire way.

That combination of individual efficiency and team dominance is rare. Most elite scorers either had to drag their team or played second fiddle to a deeper supporting cast. Bossy was the primary sniper on a team that kept winning.

Bossy played just 752 regular-season games and scored 573 goals. That’s a 0.762 goals-per-game pace. Now compare that to Ovechkin’s 853 goals in 1,426 games (0.598 GPG) or Gretzky’s 894 goals in 1,487 games (0.601 GPG).

If Bossy had played the same number of games as Gretzky, he would have scored over 1,100 goals. If he matched Gordie Howe’s 1,767 games, he’d have well over 1,300. That blows past both of them.

So if the measure is “how often did this player score, regardless of era or career length,” then prorating Bossy exposes just how far ahead he was. His career is basically the equivalent of someone stepping onto the ice, torching the league every night for 10 straight years, and walking away with no dip in performance.

Perfect Form

Today, Auston Matthews is quietly building one of the most historic goal-scoring resumes of the modern era, and the only reason it hasn’t been fully acknowledged is because it’s happening in real time, and on a team with postseason baggage.

He’s the only player in this era remotely on pace to catch or surpass Ovechkin’s goal totals, and more importantly, he’s doing it at a goals-per-game clip that aligns more with Bossy and Lemieux than with the rest of his peers. Through the end of the 2024–25 season, he’s sitting around 0.64 goals per game, which already places him in elite company, and that includes pandemic-shortened seasons that robbed him of full-year totals in his prime.

Three Rocket Richard Trophies and two runner-up finishes in less than a decade is a historic run. That’s Gretzky–Bossy-level consistency. What sets Matthews apart isn’t just his shot, it’s that he scores in every way. Off the rush, off the cycle, on one-timers, off the forecheck. He’s arguably the most complete goal scorer since Ovechkin, and maybe the most efficient technician of them all.

If he keeps this pace for another five to eight years, and stays healthy, he could land somewhere north of 750 goals. The only thing holding back his legacy isn’t his numbers. It’s the perception, no deep playoff runs, and a style of dominance that feels almost too clean to generate the narrative fireworks others have. But when you strip the drama and just look at the tape and numbers, Matthews belongs in every top-tier goal-scoring conversation. And one day, that might mean all-time.

Looking at pure goal-scoring ability, across pace, efficiency, era, and situational dominance, Mike Bossy and Mario Lemieux are in a league of their own. And the staggering part is that there was no fall-off. Bossy never dipped below 50 goals in a full season. Lemieux, meanwhile, put up 0.754 goals per game over 915 games, despite missing multiple seasons to cancer, chronic injuries, and even a retirement.

The Company They Keep

While the greatest goal scorer conversation often centers on the top handful of names, a fuller view reveals a deeper bench of legends whose scoring shaped the sport in every era. Brett Hull is one of them. With 741 goals, he ranks fourth all-time, and his three straight seasons of 70-plus in the early 1990s place him in rare company. His 86-goal campaign in 1990–91 remains second best all time to only to Gretzky’s 92 and 87 goal seasons.

And yet, Brett’s scoring DNA wasn’t built from scratch. His father, Bobby Hull, was the original template. Known as “The Golden Jet,” Bobby combined breakaway speed with a thunderous slapshot to become the first player to score more than 50 goals in an NHL season, and he led the league in goals seven times. His 610 NHL goals, plus another 303 in the WHA, give him a career total that few have matched across pro leagues.

Phil Esposito dominated a different slice of history. Between 1969 and 1975, he led the league in goals six straight times, including a then-record 76-goal season in 1970–71. He camped in the slot and turned the rebound into a weapon. He may not have had the stylistic flair of a Lemieux or the power of an Ovechkin, but his production was outrageous. Esposito was the first player to shatter the 60-goal barrier more than once, and his success redefined the center position offensively.

Maurice “Rocket” Richard was the game’s first mythological scorer. He reached 50 goals in 50 games in 1944–45, a feat so iconic it still carries his name in the trophy awarded today. He played in a 50-game season, so the margin for error was zero. His finishing ability turned him into a cultural symbol, but the numbers hold too are: eight 30-goal seasons when most of the league wasn’t even scoring 20. He led the NHL in goals five times in a ten-team league, facing the same defenders over and over. And they still couldn’t stop him.

Gordie Howe isn’t usually mentioned as a pure goal scorer, but he led the league five times and finished with 801 goals over an ironman career that spanned five decades. What sets Howe apart is his adaptability. He was an elite scorer in the Original Six era, and still putting up numbers into the 1970s. He never had the single-season highs of some peers, but his longevity and top-level consistency for twenty-plus years built a total no one came close to until Gretzky passed it.

What Could Have Been

Like Bossy, if you prorate Lemieux to 1,500 or even 1,700 games, like many of the ironmen from modern times, his totals jump into the 1,100 to 1,300 goal range. That sounds fictional, but it’s mathematically in line with his output. The production would have tapered, sure, but the point stands: both Lemieux and Bossy, had they stayed healthy, would likely sit above Ovechkin and Gretzky on the all-time list.

But there’s a difference between “could have done it” and “did it.” Bossy scored with surgical consistency. Lemieux did it with raw improvisation. Both left before their skills declined. That makes their peaks almost mythic, but it also makes comparisons harder. They didn’t have the runway to chase volume, only velocity. And in that, they were unmatched.

So who’s the greatest? That depends on what you value. Durability? Longevity? Scoring pace? Skillset? Era? One stat won’t answer it. If it did, the answer would be Ovechkin. But that only captures one dimension. Bossy and Lemieux reached the summit faster than anyone. Ovechkin stayed there longer than anyone. Gretzky made the whole mountain look small.

And when you zoom out, the picture shifts again. Greatness in goal scoring isn’t just about who got to the top. Sometimes it’s about how how long they stayed or how far ahead they were at the time. Bossy, Lemieux, Ovechkin, and Gretzky sit at the center of the debate. But they stand in a lineage where every name reshaped what goal scoring meant in their era.